Lighting Design & Specification

Feb 7, 2021

LightingBy Craig DiLouie

While “circadian lighting” varies in definition, it generally refers to design that uses intensity and spectrum of light for a non-visual effect — namely, to support regulation of circadian rhythms. A new study suggests that by enabling intensity and spectral adjustment and optimizing exposure based on time of day, designers and owners can minimize the energy trade-off imposed by associated typically much higher light levels. This would entail use of an advanced lighting control system capable of scheduled dimming and perhaps spectral emission adjustment.

Circadian lighting, or biologically effective lighting, is the culmination of decades of research, though as a design practice it is new to the lighting industry. As such, it’s evolving as ongoing research is incorporated. In the meantime, the WELL Building Standard V.2, UL Design Guideline 24480, and the Collaborative for High-Performance Schools (CHPS) Core Design Criteria 3.0 all provide lighting design recommendation and goalposts for circadian lighting implementation.

In some cases, the guidelines significantly vary, either in the primary metric used or in the target values. The primary metrics used in these guidelines are equivalent melanopic flux (EML) and circadian stimulus (CS). As an example of variation in target values, at the time the study was published, the WELL Education Pilot recommended EML ≥ 125 m-lux as an appropriate stimulus four hours per day, while CHPS recommended that EML ≥ 250 m-lux was needed. As a result, it is difficult to say what “effective implementation” truly means, as again the guidelines vary and continue to evolve as new research becomes available and is incorporated.

Meanwhile, a key question in making these guidelines actionable is the potential impact on energy use, as they may pose significant increases in indoor light levels.

This was the focus of a new study by the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), which evaluated energy use in simulated designs attempting to comply with the guidelines. Funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, the study found significant increases in indoor light levels and associated energy consumption, suggesting an energy tradeoff in realizing circadian lighting goals.

PNNL modeled an open office and classroom, varying light output, spectral emission, light distribution, task orientation, duration of stimulus exposure, and more in a series of simulations totaling 45 unique conditions. The researchers determined that current IES task light level recommendations did not satisfy EML and CS targets for either office or classroom environments.

Lighting

“In some cases, meeting the circadian metric recommendations required an average illuminance that was more than double the IES recommendations, which may negatively affect lighting quality and increase energy use,” noted the study’s authors in their report. Satisfying circadian metric recommendations in some cases also required correlated colour temperatures (CCTs) much higher than typically used in open offices and classrooms.

Overall, PNNL estimated a 10-100%increase in annual energy use depending on the number of hours per day the circadian guideline is met. The more conservative energy estimates, closer to 10-15%, involved limiting duration of circadian stimulus to four hours per day, which would most effectively be implemented using an advanced lighting control system providing what is sometimes referred to as “light showers.”

Tunable-white offers utility for circadian stimulus but presents its own trade-offs of increased complexity and modestly higher energy consumption. Another option to reduce the required quantity of electric light is daylight, though that has its own challenges, notably variability in daylight availability.

So will lighting controls be key to unlocking the potential of circadian lighting? As again the field is evolving, this remains to be seen. The study authors noted that the energy trade-off cannot be fully expressed until circadian lighting metrics and effective stimulus delivery are better understood.

As circadian lighting may require higher indoor light levels, however, advanced controls are certainly well positioned for their ability to automatically adjust intensity and spectrum based on time of day.

As shown by this study, limiting the duration of circadian stimulus by adjusting intensity and spectrum can support circadian lighting implementations while minimizing the energy trade-off. As such, lighting controls will be considered along with other factors in future research that may be undertaken to explore the trade-off and how it can be mitigated. And lighting controls should be considered when seeking to implement current circadian lighting guidelines.

Read the study here www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2020/08/f77/ssl-safranek-etal-2020_EnergyBuildings_energy-impact.pdf.

Craig DiLouie, L.C., is a lighting industry journalist, analyst and marketing consultant. Learn more at ZINGinc.com http://www.zinginc.com/  and LightNOWblog.com.​

Published with the permission of Lighting Controls Association.

Changing Scene

  • Prev
Signify is pleased to welcome their newest partner in Eastern Ontario, Greater Ottawa, and Abitibi ...
Jérôme Potvin joins the Leviton team as Customer Experience Director. He will report to Jean-Claude ...
With the launch of Liteline OnCloud in February 2021, we have been busy helping you create unique ...
As of April 4, 2022, the DLC is accepting applications to qualify products under the LUNA V1.0 ...
Liteline Corporation is pleased to announce the hiring of Mike Smith as the National Business ...
Universal Lighting Technologies and Douglas Lighting Controls, leading manufacturer and provider of ...
The DLC has announced that the new SSL and Hort application portal is officially up and running! ...
Leviton Lighting Canada (LLC) is excited to announce Jason Fisher as the new Western Regional Sales ...
The DLC is pleased to introduce our refreshed QPL logos! The new, simplified designs differentiate ...
The deadline has been extended to submit your technical papers and presentations for the 2022 ...

Changing Scene

 

LuminisLuminis announced its Bellevue and Scena luminaire families have each received a 2022 BrightStar Award from LEDs Magazine.

Like its predecessor, LEDs Magazine’s Sapphire Awards, the new BrightStar Awards recognize product developments that have advanced LED-centric solid-state lighting (SSL) components, systems, and applications into the mainstream and promoted performance capabilities beyond traditional light sources. Judges evaluated entries for their ingenuity by addressing five key factors: performance, reliability, efficiency, ease of integration/use, and innovation. Bellevue and Scena were both recognized in the Outdoor SSL category.

 

Read More


 

Design

  • Prev
In this article we explore a major refresh of lighting and controls at the province of British ...
The design team at LWG Architectural Interiors had the unique opportunity to collaborate on a pilot ...
The Illuminating Engineering Society (IES) has released their 2022 Illumination Award winners. ...
When a Massachusetts clinical-stage biopharmaceutical company relocated its head office, OLSON ...
Like millions of others across the globe, Jocelyn Trott found herself working at the dining room ...
Grace in the Kitchen is a specialty food store focused on gourmet cheeses and meats, high-end ...
 Ten iconic trees have lined Stephen Avenue in Calgary between Bankers Hall and the Core ...
San Francisco airport's Consolidated Administration Campus (CAC) Phase 1 was conceived to bring ...
Lightemotion’s consultative approach makes it unique in the field and, during a pandemic, they ...
Columbia Distributing is one of the United States’ largest distributors of alcoholic and ...

LED Technology

  • Prev
It could be argued that we have planned cities and constructed buildings to support human health ...
This summer EiKO is launching its Z10 product offering. I know, what is Z10 other than the sports ...
A new report by the IEA 4E Solid State Lighting Annex provides a look across the body of literature ...
While “circadian lighting” varies in definition, it generally refers to design that uses intensity ...
 The promotion of sustainable energy generation, the reduction of consumption in buildings and ...
Signify is introducing Trulifi at schools in Belgium to help them accelerate their ...
Lighting showrooms who offer smart home products such as light bulbs, video doorbells, door locks, ...
Ushio America (Ushio) manufactures the Care222® module using an excimer lamp. Ushio is a vertically ...
Legrand announced the publication of research showing its Indigo Clean® light disinfection ...
Amerlux announced that it now offers Delta Controls’ (DCI) all-encompassing room ...

New Products

  • Prev
GE Current, a Daintree Company has announced its newest wireless lighting controls components, the ...
Thin discs of evenly illuminated LED create the impression of recessed lighting. The die-cast ...
The LA2 Slim Rings are LightArt's answer to projects where size matters. However you choose to ...
This new flush mount offers clean lines and a wonderful semi-opaque diffuser that adds flair ...
aaline’s Reading Room series is designed for focused lighting in high traffic, commercial and ...
The Makira indoor/outdoor integrated dimmable LED flush mount fixture with a color temperature ...
A functional lamp, but with exceptional personality. Beep projects light that reflects on the wall ...
Legacy Vintage Wall Mount luminaire is the solution for indoor or outdoor applications. It shows ...
Lutron has expanded their Sunnata Touch Dimmer family that includes three new ...
Eureka announced the release of its Billie large-scale architectural luminaire. With its ...

New Products

AdvantaThe Advanta line of downlights is designed for commercial needs and feature an integrated driver, deep recessed look, and available interchangeable trims. Replacing a legacy fixture is easy: Advanta fits into the existing frame kit, ties into the junction box, and provides dimmable, energy-saving LED light. They’re ideal for both new construction and retrofit.

Advanta is available in both integral driver and remote driver (Advanta RMT) options for installation flexibility. The remote driver option is perfect for narrow plenums or obstructed spaces.

Read More


 

Kerrwil Publications Great Place to Work. Certified December 2019 - December 2020

538 Elizabeth Street, Midland,Ontario, Canada L4R2A3 +1 705 527 7666
©2022 All rights reserved

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy (effective 1.1.2016)
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Kerrwil