NEEA Studies Luminaire Level Lighting Controls

LDS Dilouie NEEA 400

Nov 6, 2020

By Craig DiLouie

The Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance (NEEA) recently published a study seeking to compare one-for-one luminaire level lighting control (LLLC) retrofits with a comprehensive networked lighting controls (NLC) redesign. Conducted by the University of Oregon, the study found that a one-for-one LLLC upgrade produced comparable energy savings and lighting quality at a competitive cost.

LLLC involves installing LED luminaires, each embedded with one or more sensors, a luminaire controller, and a dimmable driver. This allows the luminaire to operate as an independent control zone. As a typical luminaire in an open office serves 80-120 sq.ft., this results in the highest degree of granularity in responsiveness, which typically produces maximum energy savings.

The control input is occupancy- and where applicable daylight-responsive. The control output may be ON/OFF, multilevel switching or dimming, or continuous dimming. Separate manual controls allow user override.

The luminaires may operate as independent control systems or unify within a connected system via installation of a gateway, which allows programming of sequences of operation and commissioning via software. As the luminaires are individually addressable in this scheme, they can be grouped for larger zone control. Additional control strategies can be deployed such as scheduling, plug load control, individual task tuning, and institutional task tuning (demand response and/or high-end trim). If two-way communication is featured, occupancy data can be fed to a server or the Cloud for monitoring and space utilization analysis.

NEEA engaged the University of Oregon to investigate whether LLLC installed in a one-for-one LED retrofit generated energy savings and lighting quality comparable to a comprehensive NLC redesign.

The researchers set up four workstations at the center of an 891-sq.ft. space that was 33 ft. wide east-west and 27 ft. deep north-south, with perimeter glazing along the northern face, as shown in the below plan. The baseline lighting system consisted of nine 4-ft. indirect/direct 32W T8 pendant luminaires laid out on a 3×3 grid and controlled by a wall switch.

Dilouie1

Five systems were installed, which included four LLLC options of increasing features (most of them qualifying them as networked lighting control systems themselves) along with a more comprehensive NLC system. The NLC redesign system featured remote ceiling-mounted sensors (four occupancy, two daylight, configured as shown below) and software-based control zoning of luminaires as well as data output for space utilization and asset tracking. All options involved a one-for-one replacement of the fluorescent luminaires with LED luminaires tuned to produce around 30 footcandles.

diloiuie2

 

Study participants performed various tasks and responded to questionnaires that generated subjective impressions of quality of light, brightness, light distribution, visual comfort, and wellbeing. Current transformers monitored lighting power draw. Additional information was collected about ease of installation, time to install, and installed cost.

Based on the monitoring, the LLLC options generated 50-74 percent energy savings for the controls alone (not including the LED upgrade), while the NLC solution demonstrated 67 percent savings. The researchers acknowledged the space was particularly well suited to LLLC as opposed to a more comprehensive solution. The highest-performing LLLC had additional features such as scheduling, task tuning, plug load control, and energy monitoring. The NLC performed best for savings due to high-end trim but lowest for occupancy and daylight sensing, which is due to fewer sensors and less granularity in the control response. And of course the NLC provided a significant non-energy benefit related to occupancy tracking.

All of the systems installed generally smoothly and without delays, though there were some challenges in equipment acquisition. The time and complexity involved in programming and commissioning varied across the systems. Participants regarded the indirect/direct lighting favorably but without any clear preference across the control systems. In this space, the installed cost for the LLLC was roughly one-third to one-half of the NLC redesign option.

The researchers concluded the one-for-one LLLC retrofits are cost-competitive and provide comparable performance as more comprehensive NLC solutions.

Click here to download the study.

Published with the permission of the Lighting Control Association

Source

Related Articles


Changing Scene

  • July 28, 2025 - Eureka Wins Multiple SIT Furniture Design Awards

    Eureka Wins Multiple SIT Furniture Design Awards

    Eureka is pleased to announce that it has received 2025 SIT Furniture Design Awards for its Junction, Lattice, and Velia luminaires. SIT Furniture Design Award was created to celebrate and share the remarkable work of furniture designers and those who use furniture in their projects. The creativity, innovative vision, and accessibility of the furniture design… Read More…

  • Contact Delage & Solvic Announce New Representation Partnership

    New Collaboration – A New Solar Lighting Manufacturer Joins Contact Delage’s Offerings

    Contact Delage is excited to announce the addition of a new trusted partner to their lineup: Solvic, an innovative manufacturer specializing in solar lighting. This new partnership reflects Contact Delage’s ongoing commitment to offering sustainable, high-performance solutions tailored to real-world applications. With Solvic, they are expanding their range of autonomous solar products—perfect for lighting streets, parks,… Read More…


Design

  • Unboring Project: Mitchell Eye Centre by JWA Design

    Unboring Project: Mitchell Eye Centre by JWA Design

    At LightForm, they thrive on lighting projects that are anything but ordinary.​ That’s why they are excited to introduce Unboring Projects, a new series where they spotlight the spaces that subvert convention, move the needle forward, and show what is possible when great design meets bold vision. First up: the Mitchell Eye Centre in Calgary,… Read More…

  • Guidelines for Converting LED-to-LED: What Turnkey Lighting Contractors Need to Know

    Guidelines for Converting LED-to-LED: What Turnkey Lighting Contractors Need to Know

    As turnkey lighting contractors know, the wave of LED upgrades that swept across commercial and industrial buildings over the past decade brought major improvements in energy efficiency and maintenance reduction. But many of those first-generation LED systems installed between 2015 and 2020 are now entering a phase of performance decline that creates a ripe opportunity… Read More…


New Products

  • Prolux: Lumithree PT-1016 Glass Diffuser Pendant

    Prolux: Lumithree PT-1016 Glass Diffuser Pendant

    The PT-1016 is a glass diffuser that can be mounted in any room to provide an elegant touch. The diffuser comes in several translucent finishes to match any decor, and the hardware is available in a variety of powder-coated colours. Lumithree’s quality decorative lighting solutions offer their customers a diverse range of unique and flexible… Read More…

  • Magic Lite: Tri-Proof Lights

    Magic Lite: Tri-Proof Lights

    Tri-Proof Lights are a durable lighting solution that can replace traditional linear fluorescent luminaires. Tri-Proof Lights are designed for a variety of applications requiring, dust-, moisture- and impact-resistance. Suitable environments such as corridors, stairwells, warehouses, parking garages and car washes allows this versatile fixture in a variety of applications. Read More…