|

Light at Night and the Inequality Gap: Progress and Challenges

DLC Light at night, Equality

March 9, 2023

In December 2021, the DLC hosted a webinar that explored issues related to “Bridging the Inequality Gap” in outdoor nighttime lighting. The conversation introduced research on how lighting contributes to discrimination and inequity in underrepresented communities, and generated heightened interest among attendees.

To follow up on the research and work presented, the DLC sat down over Zoom with two of the 2021 webinar’s participants for an update. Below is the first of a two-part blog series based on our conversation with panel moderator and organizer Lauren Dandridge, principal of the lighting design firm Chromatic and University of Southern California architectural lighting design professor, and panelist Don Slater, Associate Professor of Sociology at the London School of Economics and Political Science.

Shortly after the DLC’s December 2021 “Responsible Lighting at Night: Bridging the Inequality Gap” webinar, moderator Lauren Dandridge expressed hope that continued dialogue about nighttime lighting and equity in the year ahead might “identify the right places to go next and illuminate pathways forward”. Talking with the DLC a year later, Dandridge and fellow webinar panelist Don Slater noted that progress is slow, but said efforts during 2022 made some headway toward easing inequities in nighttime lighting practices that have harmed the wellbeing and social fabric of marginalized neighborhoods for a century.

Positive developments, Dandridge said, included the Illumination Engineering Society’s November 2022 Light and Justice Symposium, as well as work by Light Justice, an organization formed to “create a specific home for the kinds of information that research on light and equity produce”.

“I’ve met more designers that are starting to talk about community engagement as a specific task and part of the design process in a more strategic and operational way,” Dandridge said. “I wouldn’t say it’s top of mind for every person in lighting, but it definitely has moved forward.”

International Light Equity

Across the Atlantic in England, considerations about nighttime lighting and equity issues are generally further along than in the US, said Slater, who co-leads a team of sociologists and lighting professionals exploring the role light plays in social life and how leading-edge social research can produce better lighting. While one year is too short timeframe to expect much progress, he said, “things have improved massively” compared to ten years ago “and are continuing to improve”.

Light at night as a social issue
 
Las Adelitas, a new community by Hacienda CDC in Portland Oregon, incorporates good quality lighting for the community and features an example of downward-pointing lighting that minimizes light pollution. Photo courtesy of Hacienda CDC.

“When I talk to cities or manufacturers or when I talk to residents in the community, it no longer seems strange to be connecting lighting and social issues,” Slater said, noting that “master planning” that relies on community education, involvement, and input into lighting project design is a mechanism “used widely now” in London.

On both continents, however, the dialogue around societal benefits of lighting continue to focus heavily on sustainability and cost rather than issues relating to lighting that is too bright, too dim, or wrongly placed in underrepresented communities. The misguided narrative that “more light is tied to more safety” continues to dominate, Dandridge said.

Light at Night as a Social Issue

“There’s no consideration about quality of light beyond its ties to sustainability and cost that cities are looking at. Of those three things, quality will come as the tertiary item for sure almost all the time,” she said.

What’s more, Dandridge said she fears that any momentum for equality in lighting that has built since the “strength and fervor” of the social justice movement in 2020 may wane as time passes and the movement becomes “less trendy and popular”.

Meanwhile, both Dandridge and Slater pointed to skyrocketing interest over the past year in the dark sky movement. Again, however, it’s seen mainly as an environmental, rather than social, issue.

“When dark sky gets brought up, it’s always brought up as an environmental issue, not as an equity one. No one is talking about who has access to the night sky. It’s just that there is a night sky to be seen because that’s what’s good for the planet,” Dandridge said.

Looking ahead, the “big battle”, Slater said, is for lighting design to consider communities not as monoliths but as mosaics of diverse populations – from senior citizens to teenagers – and incorporate the outdoor lighting needs of each.

“If our interest is in inequities, then our first attention has to be on differences and not use concepts that obliterate differences or make differences less visible,” he said. “How does light relate to very, very different kinds of people trying to do very different things with different kinds of resources and support? How do we share streets and how does light allow us to share streets even with conflicting needs?”

More Information Available Here

Related Articles


Changing Scene

  • LEDVANCE Expands Ontario Presence with New Specification Agent

    LEDVANCE Expands Ontario Presence with New Specification Agent

    LEDVANCE is pleased to announce the appointment of Sterling Architectural Products Ltd. (Sterling Lights) as their new specification agent in Ontario. This partnership strengthens LEDVANCE’s presence in the region and reinforces their commitment to serving the professional lighting design and specification community with innovative, reliable lighting solutions. With decades of experience and a service-driven mindset,… Read More…

  • May 29, 2025 - Eureka Wins Three 2025 Red Dot Awards for Product Design

    Eureka Wins Three 2025 Red Dot Awards for Product Design

    Eureka is pleased to announce that its Velia, Cirra, and Junction luminaires have each received a 2025 Red Dot Design Award for Product Design. It is the 11th consecutive year that Eureka products have been honored with this prestigious award, which is a testament to the company’s consistency and relentless drive to design exceptional luminaires.… Read More…


Design

  • The Difference Between Accent, Ambient & Task Lighting: Ultimate Guide

    The Difference Between Accent, Ambient & Task Lighting: Ultimate Guide

    In interior design, lighting is not just about brightening the room. Sensitive lighting layout is the key in the whole aesthetic atmosphere. An outstanding lighting solution will not rely on one type of fixture. Rather, it is through the combination of different types of lighting. Accent, ambient, and task lighting are three basic types of… Read More…

  • Graphic Office Interiors Enhance Their Office Space, Incorporating State-Of-The-Art Lighting Solutions

    Graphic Office Interiors Enhance Their Office Space, Incorporating State-Of-The-Art Lighting Solutions

    Graphic Office Interiors, a renowned office design and furnishings company serving Vancouver Island since 1966, embarked on a unique lighting project for their personal office in Saanichton, BC. This project marked the first collaboration between Kelly Inglis of Mac’s II Agencies and Graphic Office Interiors’ in-house registered interior designer, Laura Harlos. Known for their exclusive Steelcase furniture line, modular moveable… Read More…


New Products

  • Eureka Announces New Accessories for Scout Luminaire

    Eureka Announces New Accessories for Scout Luminaire

    Eureka has announced the enhancement of its Scout luminaire family with the introduction of new accessories and a new color palette. Three new diffusers have been introduced. Bell is minimalist, translucent and cloche-shaped. Pebble introduces a soft touch and an ambient glow in a distinct, oval-shaped diffuser. Orb is sleek and dome-shaped, adding a touch… Read More…

  • Amico: SOLAR ECLIPSE – 2X4 Multi-Functional Luminaire

    Amico: SOLAR ECLIPSE – 2X4 Multi-Functional Luminaire

    The Solar Eclipse Series provides a multi-functional luminaire that supports the demands of the hospital environment. The sleek and modern design merges architectural aesthetics with exceptional lighting performance to improve patient comfort while maximizing clinical efficiencies. This architectural patient room fixture offers reading, ambient, and exam functionalities and an optional night light. Multi-functional capabilities provide… Read More…