New IEA 4E SSL Annex Literature Review Offers Insights into Complex area of LED lifetime testing

LDS SSL IEA report 400

June 21, 2021

A new report by the IEA 4E Solid State Lighting Annex provides a look across the body of literature on lifetime definitions for LEDs and LED products. The reports looks at failure mechanisms, accelerated life tests and test methods for estimating lifetime, and provides some recommendations. There is currently no agreement as to which test method can best estimate the lifetime of LED lighting products and the report thus addresses a key issue for regulators and industry interested in deployment of LED technologies.

Lighting plays an essential part in everyday life, enabling people to extend their working day, improve their quality of life and expand the productivity of our workforces. However, lighting accounts for approximately 15% percent of global electricity end-use, which comes with a heavy climate and environmental impact. However, while the demand for energy services continues to grow, lighting represent one of the few areas where the energy use has been reduced globally over the last decade. This is thanks to LED technologies, which is rapidly taking over as the preferred lighting technology.

LED lighting offers many advantages such as lower energy consumption, better quality light, improved optical performance and longer lifetime than conventional lighting products. And, even though many lighting test standards have been published, there isn’t agreement as to which test method can best estimate the lifetime of LED lighting products.

Today’s reportLiterature Summary of Lifetime Testing of Light Emitting Diodes and LED Products, seeks to address this issue, by survey and summarise the literature, and make some recommendations as to which approach is best. The report draws a clear distinction between the two types of LED product failure: (1) Catastrophic failure and (2) Parametric failure.

Failure Modes

Catastrophic failure represents a change in the LED lighting system that results in sudden cessation of light output from the LED system, such as a failure in a soldered joint in the driver.  Parametric failure is characterised as a gradual change over time until the LED product is no longer producing acceptable light.  This could include for example, gradual reduction in light output or a shift in the colour of the light produced.

“Lifetime testing is a critical aspect of overall product testing for LED products,” said Professor Georges Zissis, Chair of the SSL Annex’s Management Committee and representative from France. “This report was prepared for us by the experts at the Lighting Research Centre in New York, USA and it offers a high-level summary of all the recent lifetime literature and failure mechanisms, giving guidance on which approach is deemed most effective today.”

The study found that most lifetime test method standards in use presently consider only parametric failure, the light output maintenance of the LED product. However, studies have shown that lighting products in applications can fail parametrically or catastrophically, and the literature suggests that LED system lifetime depends on both the application environment and the use pattern. Taken together, these conditions cause high LED junction temperature (which degrades the components surrounding the chip and leads to parametric failure) and thermal stress at the interconnects (which results in broken connections and leads to catastrophic failure). The study concludes therefore that to accurately estimate the life of LED lighting systems, the test method and the experiment setup must have the ability to change the environmental conditions and the on-off switching pattern.

Recommended Pathways

The report concludes by recommending two potentially successful life test methods for LED lighting systems, one being the test method adopted by the European Commission Regulation (EU) 2019/2020 which establishes a long-duration switching cycle test method that combines lumen maintenance and switching cycles into one test method.  A second promising test method is one proposed by the Lighting Research Centre and formalised by the Alliance for Solid-State Illumination Systems and Technologies (ASSIST).  The LRC method has the added advantage that it can be used to predict LED system lifetime based on specified or expected environmental conditions and use patterns, although it does not consider the influence of relative humidity as an independent variable.

Go HERE to download a copy of the report

Related Articles


Changing Scene

  • Leviton| Viscor Announces Julian Verrall as New Director of Engineering & Product Management

    Leviton|Viscor Announces Julian Verrall as New Director of Engineering & Product Management

    Leviton|Viscor is pleased to announce the appointment of Julian Verrall as their new Director of Engineering and Product Management, effective immediately. With over 13 years of experience in engineering and product management, Julian has successfully led design and new product development initiatives, demonstrating strong leadership and technical expertise. His extensive knowledge and strategic vision will… Read More…

  • Magic Lite Announces New Partnership with Prolux Lighting - Representation

    Magic Lite Announces New Partnership with Prolux Lighting

    Magic Lite is thrilled to officially join forces with the amazing team at Prolux Lighting & Controls with a new representation agreement! Thank you for the warm welcome! The Magic Lite team is excited to be part of Prolux’s strong lineup of trusted lighting brands. From kitchens to commercial projects, Magic Lite can’t wait to… Read More…


Design

  • Magic Lite: How 5CCT Ultra-Thin Recessed Ceiling Lights Deliver Maximum ROI

    Magic Lite: How 5CCT Ultra-Thin Recessed Ceiling Lights Deliver Maximum ROI

    Lighting is one of the most important aspects of any commercial or residential project, yet it is often overlooked when calculating long-term return on investment (ROI). 5CCT ultra-thin recessed ceiling lights have emerged as a game-changer, offering superior efficiency, lower installation costs, and long-term financial savings for contractors, architects, and real estate developers. Unlike traditional recessed fixtures,… Read More…

  • Artika: Spring Bathroom Lighting Upgrades for a Refreshed Space

    Artika: Spring Bathroom Lighting Upgrades for a Refreshed Space

    Refresh and revitalize your bathroom lighting. Spring brings with it an opportunity to breathe new life into our homes, starting with the spaces we use the most. The bathroom plays a crucial role in our routine, from energizing showers in the morning to relaxing baths at night. Therefore, consider upgrading your bathroom lighting to transform… Read More…


New Products

  • Zaneen: Adamas Luminaire

    Zaneen: Adamas Luminaire

    Adamas is a surface and suspension light that can elevate a space with its radiant charm. This exquisite lighting fixture is not just an illumination source; it’s an eye-catching centerpiece that adds a touch of elegance to any room. Adamas takes its inspiration from the timeless beauty of diamonds. Its multifaceted design captures and reflects light… Read More…

  • JDRF Electromag: Autonomy Sensor – Smart Lighting

    JDRF Electromag: Autonomy Sensor – Smart Lighting

    The Autonomy Sensor is an integrated control and management device that self-organizes, configures, and optimizes an advanced Smart Lighting System. A set of Autonomy Sensors collaborate to provision a secure wireless mesh network, establish Area membership based on physical co-location, and configure motion and daylight groups through the analysis of motion patterns and daylight distribution… Read More…