Can We Illuminate Our Cities and (Still) See the Stars?

Andy Holmes - Galaxy

Oct 26, 2021

S. Bará et. al/International Journal of Sustainable Lighting IJSL (2021)

Photo courtesy of

Could we enjoy starry skies in our cities again? Arguably, yes. The actual number of visible stars will depend, among other factors, on the spatial density of the overall city light emissions. In this paper it is shown that reasonably dark skies could be achieved in urban settings, even at the center of large metropolitan areas, if the light emissions are kept within admissible levels and direct glare from the light sources is avoided. These results may support the adoption of science-informed, democratic public decisions on the use of light in our municipalities, with the goal of recovering the possibility of contemplating the night sky everywhere in our planet.

A common tenet of the dark skies movement is to try to preserve the dark areas still existing in the world, avoiding their further deterioration. This position, often implemented through different figures of protection like certified Starlight Tourist Destinations [1-2], IDA’s International Dark Sky Places [3], and other astro-tourism initiatives [4-8], not only intended for pristine dark sites, but also addressing urban parks and star observing spots in polluted areas, has brought extremely significant benefits to the cause of the night and should no doubt be further promoted. Notwithstanding that, a purely defensive, reactive stance seems to be nowadays insufficient for ensuring the future of the dark nights in the planet. The persistent increase of radiance and illuminated surface [9] progressively encroaches the dark areas, reducing their size and natural values [10-12]. The dark territory to defend becomes progressively smaller and fragmentary, breaking in many cases the continuity of the nocturnal ecological corridors [13]. A related ethical and political issue is whether or not we should collectively renounce to restoring the quality of the night in areas already deteriorated, particularly in the most conspicuous ones, our urban nuclei. It is often taken for granted that the night skies are irremediably lost there, due to the huge amount of light produced in our urban agglomerations. Conventional wisdom considers the present level of emissions unavoidable. There is however an ongoing trend to reassess the validity of some “old truths” regarding the required light levels in cities: modern research fails once and again to find convincing reasons to support the actual recommendations for road lighting [14], be it in the name of a purported traffic safety, fostering of compulsive consumption, or the even less proven effect of increased photons densities when it comes to avoid some behaviors, see e.g. [15-20]. Recovering the night sky in our metropolitan areas should therefore not be discarded a priori. The explicit position of this short paper is that decidedly remediating deteriorated skies should be the option by default, and that this goal should not be abandoned excepting where and when proven unfeasible.

To download the article

Related Articles

Changing Scene

  • TALQ Consortium Released Version 2.6.0 of the Smart City Protocol

    May 24, 2024 The TALQ Consortium has released a new version 2.6.0 of its Smart City Protocol, a global interface standard for smart city device networks. Continuous evolution of the protocol ensures the interface standard constantly adapts to changing market needs. Version 2.6.0 introduces a new Cabinet Control profile, an extension of active periods and… Read More…

  • Maxlite Appoints Lance Hollner as President & Chief Executive Officer

    May 24, 2024 MaxLite is pleased to announce that its Board of Advisors has appointed Lance Hollner as its new President & CEO. A lighting industry veteran, Hollner brings over two decades of lighting expertise and knowledge to MaxLite, along with a strong track record of delivering results, driving continuous improvement, and developing talent. Much… Read More…


  • G5 Series from Eralux Illuminates the Oshawa Library

    G5 Series from Eralux Illuminates the Oshawa Library

    May 23, 2024 Eralux is proud to present its latest project with the G5 Series at the Oshawa Library to improve the atmosphere and use of public spaces. Located in downtown Oshawa, Ontario, the library is a center for learning and creativity. Now that Eralux’s innovative lighting solution has been introduced, the library experience is… Read More…

  • Luminis Wins Red Dot Award for Inline

    Luminis Wins Red Dot Award for Inline

    May 14, 2024 Luminis recently announced its Inline family has received a Red Dot Design Award for Product Design. Dating back to 1955, the Red Dot Design Award is one of the world’s largest design competitions. The Red Dot Label has become established internationally as one of the most sought-after marks of quality for good… Read More…

New Products

  • Discover Evoq Cove Lighting System from Lumenwerx

    Discover Evoq Cove Lighting System from Lumenwerx

    May 23, 2024 Lumenwerx proudly introduces Evoq, an adaptable cove lighting system comprising modular light fixtures in a plug-and-play design, several mounting options, and precision-engineered optics, among other components and features. Designed with meticulous attention to detail and a commitment to innovation, Evoq sets a new industry standard, redefining the possibilities of cove lighting. Light… Read More…

  • Airlight and CDm2 Join Forces to Offer Casambi Bluetooth Control Solutions

    Airlight and CDm2 Join Forces to Offer Casambi Bluetooth Control Solutions

    May 23, 2024 CDm2 LIGHTWORKS is excited to announce a new partnership with Airlight; the authorized Canadian partner for Casambi, offering customized, future-proof control systems utilizing low energy Bluetooth 5.3. “Partnering with Airlight enables CDm2 to deliver Casambi innovative technology to our clients in support of their diverse project requirements.” Casambi is designed to be flexible… Read More…